Supply Agreements in 2026: Abuse of the Right to Accept Goods and Ways to Protect Suppliers

A supply agreement is one of the most common types of commercial contracts in Ukraine. However, commercial litigation practice in recent years has revealed a recurring problem arising during the performance of such agreements: insufficient clarity in defining the moment of delivery and the goods acceptance procedure creates opportunities for buyers to engage in improper conduct by using the acceptance process as a means of delaying payments and claiming penalties. As a result, disputes arising from supply agreements frequently become the subject of court proceedings, and their resolution requires an in-depth understanding of substantive law.
Commercial litigation practice demonstrates a recurring pattern of buyers abusing their right to accept goods in order to delay payment or claim penalties for alleged late delivery.
Goods are delivered to the designated destination on time and are physically received by the buyer. Nevertheless, they are formally deemed not to have been delivered due to the absence of a signed acceptance certificate confirming that the goods meet the required quality standards without objections, or because the buyer raises formal quality-related claims. Buyers take advantage of the difficulties involved in objectively assessing the actual quality of goods.
This creates a paradoxical situation: the goods are physically in the buyer's possession, and the buyer may inspect them for a week or even longer, yet legally they are treated as if they had not been delivered. Payments are withheld, and the buyer may even initiate proceedings to recover penalties for alleged late delivery. These are merely different mechanisms used to pursue the same objective: avoiding the timely fulfilment of financial obligations and creating conditions for obtaining excessive financial benefits at the supplier's expense on the grounds of supposedly late delivery.
The key reason for such disputes lies in the uncertainty surrounding one fundamental contractual provision: determining the point at which the goods are deemed delivered and, accordingly, the buyer's payment obligation arises.
Many agreements contain the following wording: "The delivery date shall be the date on which the acceptance certificates confirming the quantity and quality of the goods, together with the delivery note (goods transfer and acceptance certificate), are signed."
A second significant problem arises from vague quality requirements. Instead of specifying precise parameters, standard numbers and technical characteristics, contracts often contain general wording such as "the goods must comply with state standards."
A third problem is that even where contractual quality requirements are established, buyers often interpret them at their own discretion. As a result, buyers themselves develop templates for quantity and quality acceptance certificates, determine what constitutes compliance or non-compliance, and may execute such certificates unilaterally. This lack of specificity creates room for subjective assessments and disputes.
From a practical perspective, these situations reveal a problem in the contractual regulation of supply arrangements in Ukraine: vague and ambiguous contractual provisions allow buyers to simultaneously obstruct the timely fulfilment of payment obligations and formally avoid liability despite having actual possession and use of the goods. At the contractual level, this highlights the need for clear mechanisms to monitor the actual performance of obligations and establish an objective delivery date.
Typical contractual shortcomings that contribute to such situations include:
Failure to clearly define when the buyer's payment obligation arises;
References to outdated regulations instead of specific procedures established in the agreement;
Vague or merely formal quality requirements that make objective assessment difficult;
The buyer's de facto ability to develop its own templates for quantity and quality acceptance certificates, interpret contractual requirements at its own discretion and execute such certificates unilaterally;
Absence of clearly established deadlines for submitting claims concerning visible and hidden defects;
Unclear allocation of risks and responsibilities between the parties regarding the condition and quality of the goods.
This problem is particularly acute in public procurement, where contracting authorities, relying on formal goods acceptance procedures, frequently delay the signing of acceptance certificates or impose unilateral requirements, allowing them to defer payments or obtain excessive financial benefits at the supplier's expense.
An important role in addressing this issue is played by the Resolution of the Supreme Court, Commercial Cassation Court, dated 22 August 2024 in Case No. 910/14532/23. The Court considered a situation that closely corresponded to the above-described pattern of manipulation.
The case concerned the supply of equipment. The goods were delivered on time, received by the buyer, and the initial goods acceptance and transfer certificates were signed without objections. However, the buyer subsequently submitted acceptance certificates containing quality-related claims. The buyer argued that, since the certificate had not been signed, the goods could not be considered delivered and that the supplier had therefore performed the agreement late.
In its ruling, the Supreme Court stated that goods are deemed delivered from the moment they actually arrive at the designated destination, as evidenced by the delivery note, consignment note and goods acceptance and transfer certificates.
The Court also established that the buyer's payment obligation cannot be made conditional upon the signing of an acceptance certificate confirming the absence of quality-related objections, unless the parties have expressly agreed otherwise in the contract. The presence of objections in a quantity and quality acceptance certificate does not mean that delivery, as a legal fact, has not taken place.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court expressly recognised that artificially delaying the goods acceptance procedure in order to defer payment constitutes a form of abuse of rights.
The Supreme Court's conclusions demonstrate that effective protection of suppliers' interests is possible only through detailed and precise contractual drafting. An agreement should contain a comprehensive set of provisions clearly defining the rights, obligations and liabilities of each party.
The delivery date must be clearly defined. The agreement should expressly provide that the goods are deemed delivered from the moment they arrive at the agreed destination, as confirmed by primary documents (the delivery note, consignment note and goods acceptance and transfer certificate). Acceptance of goods in terms of quality should be treated as a separate procedure.
The payment obligation must be calculated from the delivery date. If the buyer wishes to conduct an additional quality inspection, this must be expressly provided for in the agreement, together with specific time limits. For example: "The Buyer shall be entitled to conduct a quality inspection within 10 business days from the date of arrival of the goods; however, payment must be made no later than upon expiry of this period."
Deadlines for submitting claims must be clearly established. Any visible defects must be reported on the day the goods arrive. Hidden defects may be reported during the warranty period. Such provisions help prevent situations in which claims are submitted months after delivery.
The goods acceptance procedure must be comprehensively regulated. The agreement should establish a detailed procedure specifying how quality claims are to be documented, how expert examinations are to be conducted, who bears the cost of such examinations, the applicable time limits, and the subsequent steps to be taken, including replacement of the goods, refund of the purchase price or reduction of the price.
Quality requirements must be specific. Instead of vague wording such as "the goods must comply with state standards", the agreement should specify the exact numbers and designations of applicable standards (DSTU, GOST, etc.), technical parameters, references to quality certificates and other documents confirming the quality of the goods.
Delays in payment resulting from manipulation of goods acceptance procedures remain a systemic problem in Ukrainian commercial practice. Effective protection of suppliers' interests is possible only through detailed and carefully drafted contractual provisions. Clearly defining the delivery date, distinguishing it from the payment obligation, specifying quality requirements, establishing deadlines for submitting claims and providing for liability for late payment are not merely formalities, but practical tools for reducing commercial risks.
