Cash on Delivery Under Scrutiny: How Sole Proprietors Can Navigate Financial Monitoring When Working with Postal Operators

Contract law

Frozen accounts, requests to “confirm the economic substance of transactions”, and sudden refusals by banks to provide services. These are increasingly common challenges faced by entrepreneurs selling goods online with cash on delivery (COD). Brands operating through multiple individual entrepreneurs (FOPs) are particularly vulnerable. This article examines what banks and payment institutions look for and how businesses can prepare for such reviews in advance.

Why Is There Increased Scrutiny?

The “one brand, multiple FOPs” model has long been common in Ukrainian e-commerce, particularly in the clothing sector. Entrepreneurs divide responsibilities among themselves, including manufacturing, warehousing, sales and advertising, while also keeping their income within the limits applicable to the simplified taxation system. The business rationale is understandable. However, banks see a different picture: multiple accounts, one website, the same parcel senders and thousands of small payments from individuals.

Ukraine’s Law No. 361-IX of 6 December 2019, On Prevention and Counteraction to Legalization (Laundering) of the Proceeds of Crime, Financing of Terrorism and Financing of Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction, requires entities subject to primary financial monitoring to conduct proper customer due diligence (Article 11), including establishing the nature and purpose of financial transactions. For banks, these requirements are further detailed in the Regulation on Financial Monitoring by Banks, approved by Resolution No. 65 of the Board of the National Bank of Ukraine dated 19 May 2020. If a customer fails to provide the requested documents or explanations, a bank is entitled to refuse to execute a transaction or terminate the business relationship altogether (Article 15 of the Law).

Cash on delivery adds another layer of complexity. The buyer’s funds are initially received by a payment institution cooperating with the postal operator (the most well-known example is NovaPay working in conjunction with Nova Poshta) and are subsequently credited to the FOP’s bank account. This means that the transaction is analysed at least twice: by the payment institution processing the transfer and by the bank where the entrepreneur maintains their account. Each may raise its own questions.

What Triggers Compliance Departments' Attention?

Based on our experience advising such clients, three situations can most frequently lead to requests for information and account restrictions.

Turnover does not match the customer's business profile. Banks compare actual incoming payments with the declared business activities, previous turnover and the typical financial profile of entrepreneurs operating in the relevant sector. A sharp increase in COD revenue without documents explaining the origin of the goods and available stock levels may raise red flags. The bank may suspect artificial business fragmentation or the use of an account to channel funds belonging to third parties. The same applies to newly registered FOPs experiencing significant revenue growth within a short period.

The payer shown in the bank statement is not the buyer. Funds are credited to the FOP's account not directly by individual customers, but by a payment institution in a single transaction covering dozens or hundreds of shipments. Such a payment, on its own, does not explain the underlying transactions. The bank expects the entrepreneur to be able to reconcile it with specific sales by providing a transfer register, express waybill numbers, fiscal receipts and other relevant supporting documents.

Multiple FOPs operating under one brand. A shared website, trademark, warehouse and management team may indicate a single business model artificially divided among several individuals. For a bank, this raises financial monitoring concerns; for tax authorities, it may serve as grounds for suspecting artificial business fragmentation and making additional tax assessments. Therefore, the separation between FOPs must be substantive rather than merely formal, and must be supported by documents and the actual business conduct of each entrepreneur.

What Should Be Done in Advance?

Put primary accounting documents in order. The minimum set should include agreements with manufacturers and suppliers, delivery notes, acceptance certificates, documents confirming the movement of goods, express waybills, transfer registers from the payment institution, and fiscal receipts issued through a software-based registrar of settlement transactions (PRRO), where required by law. These documents should be readily available rather than collected only after receiving a bank inquiry. They form the basis of any response to the bank.

Legally separate the activities of each FOP. Where several entrepreneurs sell products under the same brand, their relationships should be formalised through appropriate agreements: supply, commission, distribution or service agreements, depending on the actual business model. The use of the trademark should also be regulated separately, potentially through a licence agreement with its owner. Each FOP should maintain independent inventory records, have a separate account with the postal operator, and be clearly identified as the seller in the website's public offer. This makes it possible to explain the funds credited to each account without referring to a “shared business”.

Respond to bank inquiries fully and on time. A request to explain the economic substance of transactions should not be ignored or answered with just a few scanned documents and no accompanying explanations. A cover letter is an effective approach: it should briefly describe the business model, the flow of goods and funds, and organise the supporting documents according to the bank's specific questions. If the bank nevertheless restricts or terminates its services, the decision may be challenged: the entrepreneur can submit a written request to the bank seeking justification for its actions, file a complaint with the National Bank of Ukraine and, if necessary, bring a claim before a court to protect their rights.

Cash on delivery remains a convenient payment method for e-commerce. However, as transaction volumes increase, so does the attention it attracts from banks and regulatory authorities. Entrepreneurs operating through multiple FOPs should proceed on the assumption that a bank inquiry is only a matter of time. A well-prepared set of supporting documents and a properly structured contractual framework make it possible to navigate such reviews while reducing the risk of account restrictions and additional tax liabilities.

Related materials

Describe the situation and a lawyer will answer today

Or write to a messenger