Property Damage to Businesses Caused by the War: How to Prove and Substantiate Losses

Business protection

The consequences of a missile strike may seem obvious: a destroyed building, damaged equipment or destroyed inventory. However, what may appear obvious in reality does not necessarily mean that all consequences have been properly proven in court.

In 2026, the Supreme Court repeatedly considered cases involving property damaged as a result of the war, in which the evidence submitted by claimants proved insufficient to satisfy their claims. The problem was not the absence of damage, but the failure to establish it with sufficient and appropriate evidence.

Photographs of a destroyed building are not enough for a court. It is necessary to establish who owned the property, what exactly happened to it, whether the damage was caused by Russia's armed aggression and, most importantly, what the monetary value of that damage is.

These issues matter not only in court proceedings. The completeness of the evidence also determines whether a business can obtain insurance compensation, benefit from a state compensation programme or submit a claim to the Register of Damage for Ukraine. Businesses should therefore understand exactly what must be proven and which documents will be required.

War Is a Matter of Common Knowledge, but Specific Damage Is Not

In its ruling dated 1 April 2026 in case No. 945/1826/24, the Supreme Court confirmed that Russia's armed aggression against Ukraine is a matter of common knowledge and does not require proof. However, this does not mean that damage to a particular building, destruction of equipment or loss of a company's inventory is also exempt from proof. Such circumstances, as well as the amount of the resulting losses, must be substantiated by the claimant with admissible evidence.

The general rules of evidence apply. Under Part 1 of Article 81 of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine and Part 1 of Article 74 of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine, each party must prove the circumstances on which it relies as the basis of its claims or objections. The fact that Russia does not participate in the proceedings or submit any objections does not release the claimant from this burden.

In case No. 344/8228/24 (ruling dated 11 March 2026), the claimants independently assessed property remaining in occupied territory based on their own descriptions and statements made during criminal proceedings. They did not submit an appraisal report or an expert opinion, nor did they request a court-appointed expert examination before the court of first instance. Their motions submitted at the appellate stage were rejected by the appellate court.

The Supreme Court also dismissed the argument that the court should have collected the evidence itself. Under Part 7 of Article 81 of the Civil Procedure Code, a court does not collect evidence on its own initiative, except in cases expressly provided for by law. The Court also noted that an expert examination could have been conducted even without physically inspecting the property.

Although both cases involved claims brought by individuals, the same principle applies to businesses: in commercial proceedings, the burden of proof likewise rests with the claimant. Therefore, the mere fact that property was destroyed or damaged as a result of shelling is insufficient to establish a successful claim.

Four Key Elements of an Evidentiary File

In a claim involving war-related damage, four circumstances must be established:

  1. The claimant's ownership of the property;

  2. The fact that the property was damaged or destroyed;

  3. The causal link between the damage and Russia's armed aggression;

  4. The amount of the losses.

1. Ownership of the Property

For real estate, the primary evidence is an extract from the State Register of Rights to Immovable Property. If ownership arose before 2013 and was not entered into the electronic register, paper title documents will be required.

For equipment and inventory, relevant evidence includes contracts, delivery notes, customs declarations, fixed asset records and trial balances.

These documents may be destroyed along with the property itself. Therefore, businesses should maintain electronic archives separately from their operational premises.

2. Evidence of Damage

For buildings, key evidence includes an inspection report prepared by a commission in accordance with Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 473 dated 19 April 2022, as well as a technical inspection report prepared by certified specialists.

Information about the damaged property should be entered into the State Register of Property Damaged and Destroyed as a Result of Hostilities.

Photographic and video evidence must make it possible to identify the relevant property. The recommended procedure is to photograph:

  • The general appearance of the building, including its address and surrounding area;

  • The damaged premises;

  • Individual items of property, including their inventory or serial numbers.

Original files should be preserved rather than relying solely on copies received through messaging applications.

3. Causal Link to the War

The causal link may be established through materials from criminal proceedings, including a report submitted to the police, an extract from the Unified Register of Pre-Trial Investigations and an incident scene inspection report.

Additional evidence may include official announcements issued by military administrations regarding the attack, CCTV recordings and witness statements.

If fragments of ammunition or explosive devices are found at the scene, they must not be touched. The police or the State Emergency Service should be notified, as such items may constitute physical evidence.

4. Assessment of the Amount of Damage

This is often the decisive element of the claim and therefore deserves separate consideration.

The amount of damage cannot be substantiated through approximate calculations made by the business itself. For companies, the applicable procedure is established by Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 326 dated 20 March 2022 and the Methodology approved by Joint Order No. 3904/1223 of the Ministry of Economy and the State Property Fund dated 18 October 2022.

The amount of damage may be confirmed by an appraisal report or an expert opinion.

An appraisal report is generally required for insurers, state compensation programmes and the Register of Damage for Ukraine, and courts also accept it as evidence.

If no appraisal report is available or its conclusions are questionable, an expert examination may be necessary. It can be commissioned independently (Article 106 of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine and Article 101 of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine) or requested through the court.

This should be done at the court of first instance. Case No. 344/8228/24 demonstrates that it may be too late to raise such a request at the appellate stage.

Particular attention should be paid to the valuation of equipment.

The book value of a machine purchased ten years ago may be close to zero due to depreciation. However, it would be impossible to purchase an equivalent machine for that amount.

Article 1192 of the Civil Code of Ukraine provides that:

"The amount of damages payable to the injured party shall be determined based on the actual value of the lost property at the time the case is considered, or the cost of works necessary to restore the damaged property."

Therefore, when commissioning an appraisal, it is important to expressly specify that the assessment should determine the actual value of the property, meaning the cost of acquiring equivalent equipment, rather than its book value.

Loss of profits is more difficult to prove.

Simply stating that a business could have earned a certain amount of profit but for the shelling is insufficient. Claims for damages cannot be based on assumptions.

Under Part 4 of Article 623 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, when determining lost profits, the measures taken by the injured party to obtain the relevant income must be taken into account.

A practical example is commercial case No. 905/858/22.

The claimant was a subcontractor at the Azovstal Metallurgical Plant in Mariupol and was unable to perform its contractual obligations due to the full-scale invasion.

The court of first instance dismissed the claim for lost profits. However, by its ruling dated 13 June 2024, the Eastern Commercial Court of Appeal overturned that decision and awarded UAH 25,358,240 in damages against Russia.

The commencement of contractual performance was confirmed by materials delivered to the plant's premises and an interim acceptance certificate dated 25 February 2022. The amount of lost profits was established through a court-appointed forensic economic examination.

Accordingly, to substantiate a claim for lost profits, a business should collect contracts and specifications, documents confirming advance payments, purchased raw materials and preparations for fulfilling orders, as well as financial statements for previous years.

Such evidence demonstrates that the business did not merely expect to earn a profit but had already taken specific steps to generate that income.

Conclusions

In claims for compensation for damage caused by Russia's armed aggression, it is not enough to refer to the fact of war and the damage to property.

The claimant must prove specific circumstances: ownership of the property, the fact and nature of the damage, its connection with Russia's armed aggression and the substantiated amount of losses.

Therefore, evidence collection should begin immediately after the property has been damaged, rather than only when preparing a statement of claim.

Timely documentation of the consequences of shelling, properly preserved property records and evidence confirming the value of the damaged assets may prove decisive in obtaining compensation.

Related materials

All news

Describe the situation and a lawyer will answer today

Or write to a messenger