Criminal Proceedings as a Tool of Pressure on Business: Where Is the Line Between Criminal Investigation and Interference in Business Activities, and What Are the Available Remedies

Business protection

Criminal Proceedings as a Tool of Pressure on Business: Where Is the Line Between Criminal Investigation and Interference in Business Activities, and What Are the Available Remedies?

In today's environment, Ukrainian businesses must not only protect themselves against actions by the aggressor state but also guard against unlawful interference by law enforcement agencies in their business activities.

However, the registration of information concerning a criminal offence in the Unified Register of Pre-Trial Investigations (URPI) and the initiation of criminal proceedings do not necessarily mean that a company has become the target of unlawful pressure.

Under the current criminal procedure legislation, law enforcement authorities are empowered to verify information about possible criminal offences during pre-trial investigations. They are also required to examine all circumstances of criminal proceedings comprehensively, thoroughly and impartially, identifying both circumstances that incriminate and those that exonerate a suspect or accused person. Nevertheless, the line between conducting a pre-trial investigation and interfering with business activities is crossed when procedural measures lack proper justification, do not correspond to the purpose of the proceedings or impose disproportionate restrictions on a company.

When considering the circumstances that may lead to the initiation of criminal proceedings, particular attention should first be paid to corporate disputes between business entities in which criminal law mechanisms are used as a means of exerting pressure on business partners. Another reason for entering information into the Unified Register of Pre-Trial Investigations is the independent identification by law enforcement authorities of circumstances which, in their opinion, may indicate the commission of a criminal offence. In practice, the grounds for entering such information often include reports prepared by law enforcement officers following an analysis of available information or operational activities.

Pursuant to Part 1 of Article 214 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, an investigator or prosecutor is required to enter relevant information into the Unified Register of Pre-Trial Investigations where circumstances indicating a possible criminal offence exist and to commence a pre-trial investigation. At the same time, the mere fact that information about a criminal offence has been entered into the Register, regardless of its source, should not be regarded as proof that the elements of the alleged crime have been established or that a particular company or its officers are involved. These circumstances must be duly proven during the pre-trial investigation.

Therefore, a company and its officers should not only establish the grounds on which criminal proceedings were initiated but also provide a proper legal assessment of the subsequent actions taken by law enforcement authorities. Not every criminal proceeding involving a company's business activities constitutes unlawful pressure by law enforcement agencies.

At the same time, the following circumstances may indicate that criminal proceedings are being used as a tool to interfere with a company's business activities:

  • The absence of an apparent connection between the subject matter of the pre-trial investigation and the company's business activities;

  • An unjustified expansion of the investigation to include other financial and business transactions or periods of the company's operations that have no connection with the subject matter of the investigation or the circumstances to be established in the criminal proceedings;

  • Repeated investigative and procedural actions without an apparent necessity;

  • Seizure during a search of property that has no evident evidentiary value for the criminal proceedings.

Accordingly, distinguishing a lawful pre-trial investigation from unlawful pressure on business requires more than examining an individual procedural decision made by an investigator or prosecutor. It is necessary to assess the totality of relevant circumstances, including the existence of factual grounds for interference, its consistency with the purpose of the criminal proceedings, compliance with procedural safeguards and the actual consequences for the company's business operations. Developing a defence strategy should begin with precisely this assessment.

First Step in Defence: Establishing the Exact Subject Matter of the Pre-Trial Investigation

First and foremost, it is necessary to establish the legal qualification of the alleged offence under which the pre-trial investigation is being conducted, which financial and business transactions are being examined, the relevant period, and the procedural status of the company's officers.

It is important not to rely solely on the general assumption that the investigation concerns the company's activities. At this stage, the company should already begin building its own documentary evidence base, including contracts, supplementary agreements, certificates of completed works, primary accounting documents, payment orders, correspondence and documents confirming the actual performance of contractual obligations.

Second Step in Defence: Responding Properly to Searches and Property Seizures

During a search, the company's representative, together with legal counsel, should verify the court order, the address, the scope of authorised actions and the list of items and documents permitted to be searched for. Any objections concerning the conduct of the investigative action should be recorded in the search protocol. The seizure of property must also be documented, with a detailed inventory obtained.

Particular attention should be paid to the seizure of equipment, servers, electronic storage devices and documents without which the company cannot operate effectively.

Following a search, it is also essential to establish the legal status of the seized property. The status of each seized item must be assessed in light of the search warrant, the search protocol and subsequent procedural decisions.

If the seized property was not expressly specified in the investigating judge's order and no identifying characteristics of such property were indicated by the judge, it is considered temporarily seized property. In such cases, the investigator must comply with the relevant procedures and deadlines established by Article 171 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

It is therefore necessary to verify whether the deadlines for filing a motion for seizure of property have been observed. Where there are grounds to establish that the relevant deadlines for applying to the court were violated, the company may demand the immediate return of its property. If an asset seizure order has been issued, the company may initiate proceedings to have it lifted pursuant to Article 174 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine.

Third Step in Defence: Do Not Leave Procedural Restrictions Unchallenged

If investigators request documents from business partners or the company pursuant to Article 93 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, summon and question employees, or restrict access to criminal case materials necessary for developing a defence strategy, the company should assess not only the formal legality of such actions but also whether they infringe upon its rights and legitimate interests.

Requests for a company's financial and business documents under Article 93 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine may constitute unlawful demands where the statutory requirements for obtaining such documents have not been met and the procedure prescribed by law has not been followed.

Furthermore, employees should be aware of their procedural rights, including the right guaranteed by Article 63 of the Constitution of Ukraine not to testify against themselves or their close relatives.

All communications addressed to investigators and prosecutors should preferably be submitted in writing, with clear legal reasoning and evidence confirming their submission.

Fourth Step in Defence: Building an Independent Evidentiary Position

Many companies receive a request from law enforcement authorities to provide documents, submit their response and assume that the matter will end there. However, this may be the first indication that the company has attracted the attention of law enforcement authorities.

In such circumstances, a company should not wait for the pre-trial investigation authority to independently examine all aspects of its business activities. Instead, it can and should take the initiative in collecting its own evidence demonstrating the transparency and legality of its business operations.

Such evidence-gathering measures may include submitting requests through legal counsel, obtaining documents from business partners, and engaging relevant specialists and experts.

Where the subject matter of the investigation involves alleged losses to the state or a business partner, the reality of business transactions or the valuation of assets, it is advisable to examine the methodology used in the relevant calculations and verify whether they are consistent with the primary accounting documents.

In such cases, an expert examination and expert opinion may serve as particularly important tools for verifying and challenging the validity of allegations made by the pre-trial investigation authority.

Fifth Step in Defence: Using Institutional Protection Mechanisms and Public Advocacy

To protect its rights, a company should not limit itself to submitting applications and complaints to investigators, prosecutors or courts.

Where the actions of law enforcement authorities demonstrate signs of systematic and unjustified interference with business activities, the company should consider approaching the Business Ombudsman Council, the Federation of Employers of Ukraine and the STOP PRESSURE platform.

An appeal to the Business Ombudsman Council may be an effective instrument where a company believes that a law enforcement authority has acted in bad faith or violated its rights.

To submit a complaint, the company should prepare a written description of the situation and provide documentary evidence of specific actions or omissions by law enforcement officials.

The complaint should be accompanied by copies of relevant procedural decisions issued by investigators, prosecutors and investigating judges; search protocols; motions submitted to the pre-trial investigation authority requesting the return of seized property; responses from investigators and prosecutors to such motions; court decisions; and evidence demonstrating the actual impact on the company's business activities.

When submitting an application or complaint to the Business Ombudsman Council, the applicable complaint review requirements should be taken into account. In particular, the company should indicate whether it has previously approached the relevant state authorities to resolve the issue and whether the matter is currently being considered by a court.

Following its review of the complaint and confirmation of the issues raised, the Council may organise joint meetings involving business representatives, their legal counsel and the management of the relevant law enforcement authority in order to seek an out-of-court resolution.

Another institutional mechanism for interaction between businesses and public authorities is the Federation of Employers of Ukraine.

Where a problematic situation arises, a company may approach the Federation through its relevant structures, including the Committee for the Protection of Business and Property Rights, to initiate consideration of the matter and draw attention to its impact on business operations.

The STOP PRESSURE platform may also be used to document problematic cases and initiate professional dialogue with the relevant law enforcement authorities.

When submitting an appeal to the Federation of Employers of Ukraine, the company should prepare a concise description of the alleged unlawful pressure affecting its business activities, a chronological account of events, a list of procedural violations attributed to the pre-trial investigation authority and supporting documentation.

At the same time, it is important to understand that attracting public attention is not, in itself, a means of resolving the problem. Public advocacy should aim to draw attention to possible violations by law enforcement authorities and protect the company's rights and legitimate interests.

Public statements should be based on verified facts, should not substitute for circumstances established by a court and should not contain unsubstantiated allegations against law enforcement authorities.

A position supported by documentary evidence provides the foundation for a substantive review and resolution of the issue.

Thus, effective business protection should not be limited to challenging the mere existence of criminal proceedings.

The foundation of an effective defence is a consistent approach aimed at verifying the grounds for the investigation, preserving documents, challenging specific procedural decisions, developing an independent evidentiary position with the involvement of specialists and experts, and engaging institutions capable of assisting in the protection of the company's rights.

This approach enables businesses to defend their legitimate interests without automatically equating a lawful investigation with a conflict involving law enforcement authorities, while at the same time preventing criminal proceedings from becoming a means of unjustified interference in business activities.

Related materials

All news

Describe the situation and a lawyer will answer today

Or write to a messenger