Coordination and Cooperation of Public Authorities in Protecting the Financial Interests of Ukraine and the European Union

Relationships involving the coordination and cooperation of public authorities acquire an administrative-law character when they arise and are carried out on the basis of administrative law provisions. The requirement set out in Part Two of Article 19 of the Constitution of Ukraine remains applicable even in cases involving coordinated activities of several authorities: each authority is obliged to act on the basis of, within the limits of, and in the manner prescribed by the Constitution and laws of Ukraine. Accordingly, the achievement of a common objective does not eliminate the institutional separation of powers between authorities, nor does it entitle one authority to assume the powers of another.
The Law of Ukraine "On the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine" assigns the Government the authority to direct and coordinate the activities of ministries and other central executive authorities. The Law of Ukraine "On Central Executive Authorities" also uses the concept of coordination to describe organisational influence within the executive branch. However, the substance of a coordination relationship is determined not by its designation, but by the powers granted by law and the legal consequences of decisions made by the coordinating entity.
Classical legal doctrine classifies coordination as an organisational relationship alongside subordination, supervision and accountability. At the same time, coordination between legally equal administrative structures is recognised as possible, including on a contractual basis. It follows that coordination does not necessarily establish a vertical relationship of authority; it may serve as a means of aligning the activities of entities, each of which retains the competence assigned to it by law.
In the area under consideration, coordination serves an organisational purpose. The protection of the financial interests of Ukraine and the European Union falls within the remit of different authorities, each of which applies the legal instruments available to it. Within the national framework, specific tasks relating to the identification of irregularities, the implementation of control measures, the transfer of materials and the elimination of the consequences of violations are assigned to different entities. It is precisely this distribution of powers that makes proper coordination and cooperation necessary.
A coordinating entity does not acquire a general right to direct all participants. It may establish channels for information exchange, coordinate the sequence of actions, organise joint consideration of issues, prevent duplication of functions and consolidate results. Binding instructions, inspections or the application of enforcement measures are permissible only where a separate legal provision expressly grants the relevant authority.
Coordination must be distinguished from subordination. The latter involves a stable vertical relationship and the exercise of authoritative powers by a superior body over a subordinate one. Interagency coordination does not create such a general relationship. The existence of a designated coordinator is typical of an institutionally established mechanism; however, this fact alone does not grant the coordinator the right to interfere in matters falling within the jurisdiction of another authority.
Control has a different immediate purpose: establishing the factual circumstances and assessing whether activities comply with legal requirements. The application of legally prescribed enforcement measures constitutes a legal consequence of identified violations and depends on the competence of the relevant authority. Supervision is likewise associated with verifying compliance with the law. Academic studies on the coordinating activities of the prosecution service emphasise their organisational nature and the inadmissibility of equating coordination with supervision. Accordingly, participation in coordination does not create control or supervisory powers in the absence of an express legal basis.
Cooperation is manifested through the coordinated performance of specific actions by the participating entities. While coordination addresses the question of how to organise the activities of several authorities, cooperation demonstrates how those authorities exercise their respective powers in connection with one another. It takes the form of specific coordinated actions undertaken by entities within the scope of their respective powers and in legally prescribed forms.
Such forms may include information exchange, coordination of decisions, execution of requests, referral of materials to the competent authorities, joint planning, working groups and assistance during inspections. Their scope depends on the legal status of the participants and the subject matter of their activities. Control remains an independent function: cooperation may facilitate its organisation but does not replace the relevant control powers.
Consistency of action does not mean uniformity. Each authority performs its own tasks and uses the instruments available to it. It is precisely the distribution of functions that creates the need for cooperation. What matters is not complete equality between participants, but the preservation of their institutional independence: the actions of one authority may create the conditions for another authority to act, but they do not confer the right to substitute its own decisions for those of the latter.
Cooperation must also be distinguished from collaboration. The latter may encompass long-term partnership relations, training, consultations and the exchange of experience that are not necessarily connected with the exercise of a specific public authority power. Cooperation within the national mechanism has a defined connection with the performance of the tasks assigned to its participants. Article 325 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union uses the term "cooperation" to describe relations between the competent authorities of Member States and the Commission. Therefore, this term should not automatically be equated with the legal concept of "interaction" used in Ukrainian legislation.
Doctrinal approaches to the relationship between coordination and cooperation differ: the concepts are sometimes treated as identical, one is regarded as a form of the other, or they are considered independent phenomena. For the national mechanism, the latter position is more convincing. Treating the concepts as identical eliminates the distinction between organisational influence and direct actions, while classifying one concept as a broader category encompassing the other fails to account for the fact that cooperation can exist even without a permanent coordinating entity.
Within the mechanism under consideration, coordination primarily performs an organisational function by ensuring the alignment of participants' activities, whereas cooperation is manifested through specific interrelated actions undertaken by those participants. Coordination activities may take place in the form of cooperation, for example during a joint meeting or the approval of a draft decision. However, this demonstrates the interconnectedness of the concepts rather than their identity.
Coordination between public authorities in the field of protecting the financial interests of Ukraine and the European Union may be defined as an organisational activity governed by administrative law provisions and aimed at aligning the objectives, tasks, sequence and methods of activities of entities, each of which operates within the limits of its own competence.
Cooperation in this field constitutes the coordinated performance by public authorities, within the scope of their respective competences, of interrelated actions in legally established organisational and procedural forms. Emphasising mutual interdependence makes it possible to distinguish cooperation from an abstract notion of joint activity: the actions of one participant must have a legal or factual connection with the proper exercise of the powers of another.
The regulatory formula "coordination of cooperation" reflects this relationship. The object of organisational influence is the coordinated activity of authorities, rather than their competence or overall functioning. Under this interpretation, the regulatory concept of "coordination of cooperation" acquires independent meaning, provided that the relevant legal act defines the entities responsible for coordination and cooperation, their powers, the forms of their relationships and the legal consequences of their respective actions.
The current regulatory framework generally confirms this distinction. Resolution No. 1110 provides for the establishment of an Interagency Coordination Council and a special procedure for interagency cooperation. The Interagency Coordination Council is a temporary consultative and advisory body of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. This status does not confer general administrative management powers over the entities participating in cooperation; the legal significance of its activities is determined by the tasks and forms of operation established in its Regulations.
Following the amendments introduced in 2024, the functions of the Anti-Fraud Coordination Service (AFCOS) were assigned to the State Audit Service of Ukraine. This concerns specific coordination and information-related powers exercised by an existing central executive authority, rather than the establishment of a body with universal authority over the participating entities. The substance and limits of these powers must be determined through a combined interpretation of Resolutions No. 43, No. 1110 and No. 1031.
Interagency cooperation is carried out through the designation of authorised representatives, information exchange, submission and consideration of irregularity reports, requests for additional information and the referral of information to the competent authorities. These are specific forms through which mutual rights and obligations are exercised. Their proper implementation requires clearly defined deadlines, requirements concerning the content of notifications, rules for information protection and liability for the accuracy of the information provided.
The official definition of AFCOS's role in the European Union also combines coordination with cooperation. The national service ensures communication with OLAF and, depending on the internal organisation of the respective state, coordinates legislative, administrative and investigative tasks related to the protection of the Union's financial interests. This does not establish a single model of subordination, but rather leaves the determination of AFCOS's institutional position and powers to national law.
Article 325 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union consistently distinguishes between the coordination of Member States' actions and the cooperation of competent authorities with the Commission. This framework provides for the involvement of various authorities in preventing, detecting and investigating violations, as well as remedying their consequences. The implementation of the relevant measures does not alter the statutory competence of these authorities, as follows from the general requirements governing the activities of public authorities.
Further improvement of the regulatory framework should focus not on replacing the formula "coordination of cooperation", but on consistently clarifying its substance. Regulatory acts should separately define the entity responsible for coordination and the scope of its powers, the range of participating entities and forms of cooperation, as well as control powers and enforcement measures. Such a distinction makes it possible to establish the legal consequences of decisions and requests, deadlines for their execution and the liability of each participant.
Conclusions
Coordination and cooperation between public authorities in the field of protecting the financial interests of Ukraine and the European Union are related but independent administrative-law concepts. Their common feature is their focus on achieving a legally defined objective through coordinated efforts; their distinction lies in their immediate purpose. Within the mechanism under consideration, coordination primarily performs an organisational function, while cooperation is manifested through specific interrelated actions undertaken by its participants.
Coordination in this field constitutes organisational activity governed by administrative law provisions and aimed at aligning the objectives, tasks, sequence and methods of activities of entities, each of which operates within the limits of its own competence. Cooperation is expressed through the coordinated performance of interrelated actions by these entities in legally established forms and procedures. The two concepts cannot be understood as a simple relationship between a general category and its specific form.
The formula "coordination of cooperation between public authorities" has independent legal significance: the subject of coordination is the joint activity of public authorities, rather than their competence as such. Coordination must not be equated with subordination, control or supervision, while cooperation must not be reduced solely to information exchange.
Regulatory acts should consistently distinguish between coordination powers, forms and procedures of cooperation, and control measures. The legal consequences of failure to fulfil established obligations require separate regulatory definition, particularly in cases involving failure to meet deadlines for providing information and other mandatory requirements within the relevant mechanism.
